The Sixty Two NYCBOOK NOW

Where to Stay in New York If You Want It Quiet: The Blocks We'd Pick

By ·

Quick answer

The quietest places to stay in Manhattan are the residential side streets east of Third Avenue, roughly from the East 50s up to the East 80s: Sutton Place, the East 60s in Lenox Hill, Turtle Bay, Carnegie Hill and Yorkville. They're quiet for structural reasons, not luck. No bus routes on the side streets, almost no bars, no nightlife crowd walking home at 2am, and buildings full of people who live here year-round. If you want to sleep in New York, pick a cross street rather than an avenue, and ask for a room that faces the back.

A quiet Upper East Side street at the end of the day, cars parked along the curb.
The Upper East Side at dusk. Most of the blocks around us look like this after 8pm. · Photo by Clay LeConey on Unsplash

The short answer

Stay on a residential cross street east of Third Avenue, anywhere from the East 50s to the East 80s. That's the quietest band of Manhattan you can book a bed in, and it covers Sutton Place, the East 60s in Lenox Hill, Turtle Bay, Carnegie Hill and Yorkville. We live and work on East 62nd Street, so this is the part of town we can speak about honestly.

Quiet in New York isn't about how nice a building is. It's about what's on your block and what's on the corner.

What actually makes a New York block loud

Four things, in order:

  1. Bus routes and truck routes. The avenues carry them. Cross streets mostly don't. Moving one block off an avenue does more for your sleep than any window upgrade.
  2. Bars and clubs. Not the noise inside them, the noise outside at closing: people saying goodbye at length, and the cars idling to collect them.
  3. Hotel density. Where hotels cluster, so do coaches, luggage carts and 6am airport pickups.
  4. Sirens. Hospitals and fire houses generate them, and no window stops them completely. Worth knowing, not worth panicking about.

Notice that none of these are about the neighbourhood's reputation. There are expensive blocks that are loud and plain blocks that are silent.

The quiet list, in the order we'd book it

Sutton Place, East 53rd to East 59th between First Avenue and the river. The quietest few blocks in Manhattan that still have a subway within walking distance. It dead-ends at the East River, so there's no through traffic and no reason for anyone to drive down it. Almost entirely apartment buildings full of long-term residents. Nothing happens here after nine, which is exactly the point.

Lenox Hill, the East 60s cross streets. Our stretch. East 62nd between First and Second is townhouses and small apartment buildings, and by 9pm the loudest thing outside is somebody walking a dog. Second Avenue two doors over has traffic, and you'll hear an ambulance now and then heading up First or York towards the hospitals in the East 60s and 70s. In exchange, you're eight minutes from Central Park's Fifth Avenue entrance at 60th Street and two blocks from the F and Q at Lexington Avenue and 63rd.

Turtle Bay, east of Second in the East 40s and 50s. Officially Midtown, which scares people off, and then you get there and it's brownstones and gardens. It empties out at night because the offices to the west close. Good if you want quiet and a short walk to Grand Central.

Carnegie Hill, East 86th to East 96th near Fifth and Madison. Wide sidewalks, school-run mornings, then nothing. It's a longer trip to everything downtown, so treat that as the trade.

Yorkville, east of Second in the East 70s and 80s. The most residential of the lot, cheapest of the lot, and the furthest from a subway if you're east of Second. Fine if you like walking.

Places people book anyway, then complain about

Times Square is the obvious one. It's loud at 3am on a Tuesday, and no room faces away from all of it. The Lower East Side and Nolita are wonderful and impossible on Friday and Saturday nights. Meatpacking is the same story with better restaurants. Around Penn Station you get buses, sirens and a construction pit that has outlived several presidents. None of these are bad neighbourhoods. They're just not sleeping neighbourhoods.

Getting a quiet room once you've picked the block

  • Ask for a unit that faces the back of the building, or an interior courtyard, not the street.
  • Higher isn't automatically quieter. Street noise travels up. Facing matters more than floor.
  • Avoid ground-floor rooms next to a restaurant's exhaust or a bar's door.
  • Check what's on the two nearest corners on a map before you book. A bar on the corner is louder than a bar three doors down.
  • Residential blocks get overnight garbage collection. It's a truck, it's brief, and it's the price of not living above a nightclub.

Why we're on East 62nd Street

We chose this block on purpose. Midtown's best blocks are the quiet ones, and this is one of them: residential, mid-block, with the park on one side and the river on the other. Everything you'd actually walk to is within a few minutes, and nothing outside your window has a last call. Stay three nights or three weeks, it's your apartment, and there's no lobby or key card between you and the front door. We text you the code the day before you arrive.

If you want to see how the quiet blocks connect to each other on foot, our Sutton Place and Turtle Bay guides are the route we'd walk you on the first evening.

Common questions

What is the quietest neighborhood to stay in in New York City?

Sutton Place, roughly East 53rd to East 59th Street between First Avenue and the East River. It dead-ends at the river, so there's no through traffic, and it's almost entirely residential buildings with no nightlife. The residential cross streets of Lenox Hill, Turtle Bay, Carnegie Hill and Yorkville are close behind.

Is the Upper East Side quiet at night?

The cross streets are, yes. The avenues carry buses and traffic, so the difference between a cross street and an avenue is bigger than the difference between neighborhoods. Ambulances heading to the hospitals in the East 60s and 70s are the one noise you can't design around.

How do I make sure my room is quiet?

Ask for a back-facing unit rather than a street-facing one, check what's on the two nearest corners on a map, and skip ground-floor rooms next to a restaurant or bar door. Facing matters more than which floor you're on.

Is it inconvenient to stay somewhere quiet in Manhattan?

Not on the East Side. From East 62nd Street, Central Park's Fifth Avenue entrance at 60th Street is about an eight-minute walk and the F and Q trains are two blocks away at Lexington Avenue and 63rd Street. You're trading nightlife on your doorstep, not access.

Is there a front desk, or how do we get in late at night?

There's no lobby and no key card. We text you your door code before you arrive, so a late flight or a 1am arrival is fine. Come and go as you please, and text us if anything's off.

Book your stay at The Sixty Two NYC